| Blyth Spartans v Buxton 10/02/2024 | View match | |
| Spennymoor Town F.C. v Blyth Spartans 17/02/2024 | View match | |
| Farsley Celtic v Blyth Spartans 20/02/2024 | View match | |
| Blyth Spartans v Boston United 24/02/2024 | View match | |
| Tamworth v Blyth Spartans 02/03/2024 | View match | |
| Blyth Spartans v Kings Lynn Town 09/03/2024 | View match | |
| Blyth Spartans v Darlington FC 12/03/2024 | View match | |
| Southport v Blyth Spartans 16/03/2024 | View match | |
| Peterborough Sports v Blyth Spartans 23/03/2024 | View match | |
| Blyth Spartans v Curzon Ashton 29/03/2024 | View match | |
| Chorley v Blyth Spartans 01/04/2024 | View match | |
| Blyth Spartans v Rushall Olympic 06/04/2024 | View match |