| Oldham Athletic FC v York City FC 19/09/2023 | View match | |
| Woking FC v York City FC 23/09/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Barnet FC 26/09/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Solihull Moors 30/09/2023 | View match | |
| Dagenham & Redbridge v York City FC 03/10/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Bromley FC 07/10/2023 | View match | |
| Eastleigh v York City FC 21/10/2023 | View match | |
| Chesterfield FC v York City FC 24/10/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v FC Halifax Town 28/10/2023 | View match | |
| Chester FC v York City FC 04/11/2023 | View match | |
| AFC Fylde v York City FC 11/11/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Chester FC 14/11/2023 | View match |