| Peterhead v Arbroath FC 01/08/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v Dumbarton 15/08/2009 | View match | |
| East Fife FC v Arbroath FC 22/08/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v St Johnstone FC 26/08/2009 | View match | |
| Stenhousemuir FC v Arbroath FC 29/08/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v Brechin City FC 12/09/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v Peterhead 19/09/2009 | View match | |
| Alloa Athletic FC v Arbroath FC 26/09/2009 | View match | |
| Stirling Albion FC v Arbroath FC 10/10/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v Clyde 14/10/2009 | View match | |
| Arbroath FC v Cowdenbeath FC 17/10/2009 | View match | |
| Dumbarton v Arbroath FC 24/10/2009 | View match |