| Carlisle United FC v Exeter City FC 04/10/1958 | View match | |
| Exeter City FC v Aldershot F.C 08/10/1958 | View match | |
| Northampton Town FC v Exeter City FC 11/10/1958 | View match | |
| Exeter City FC v Workington 18/10/1958 | View match | |
| York City FC v Exeter City FC 25/10/1958 | View match | |
| Gateshead v Exeter City FC 27/10/1958 | View match | |
| Exeter City FC v Bradford Park Avenue 01/11/1958 | View match | |
| Port Vale FC v Exeter City FC 08/11/1958 | £15.00 | |
| Brentford FC v Exeter City FC 15/11/1958 | View match | |
| Chester City FC v Exeter City FC 22/11/1958 | View match | |
| Exeter City FC v Watford FC 29/11/1958 | View match | |
| Exeter City FC v Southport 13/12/1958 | View match |