| Grimsby Town FC v Guiseley AFC 02/01/2016 | View match | |
| Welling United v Grimsby Town FC 09/01/2016 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Altrincham 23/01/2016 | View match | |
| Gateshead v Grimsby Town FC 30/01/2016 | View match | |
| Bromley FC v Grimsby Town FC 09/02/2016 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Boreham Wood 13/02/2016 | View match | |
| FC Halifax Town v Grimsby Town FC 20/02/2016 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Woking FC 23/02/2016 | View match | |
| Forest Green Rovers v Grimsby Town FC 04/03/2016 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Southport 08/03/2016 | View match | |
| Guiseley AFC v Grimsby Town FC 15/03/2016 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Wrexham FC 26/03/2016 | View match |