| Newton Heath v Lincoln City FC 12/09/1896 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Newton Heath 19/09/1896 | View match | |
| Walsall FC v Newton Heath 21/09/1896 | View match | |
| Newton Heath v Newcastle United FC 26/09/1896 | View match | |
| Manchester City FC v Newton Heath 03/10/1896 | View match | |
| Newton Heath v Small Heath 10/10/1896 | View match | |
| Blackpool FC v Newton Heath 17/10/1896 | View match | |
| Gainsborough Trinity v Newton Heath 21/10/1896 | View match | |
| Newton Heath v Burton Wanderers 24/10/1896 | View match | |
| Newton Heath v Grimsby Town FC 07/11/1896 | View match | |
| Small Heath v Newton Heath 28/11/1896 | View match | |
| Notts County FC v Newton Heath 19/12/1896 | View match |