| Pilgrims v Marlow FC 09/10/1873 | View match | |
| Sheffield F.C v Pilgrims 22/11/1873 | View match | |
| Pilgrims v South Norwood 10/10/1874 | View match | |
| Clapham Rovers v Pilgrims 05/12/1874 | View match | |
| Old Etonians v Pilgrims 09/11/1875 | View match | |
| Pilgrims v Ramblers 14/10/1876 | View match | |
| Pilgrims v Panthers 09/12/1876 | View match | |
| Wanderers v Pilgrims 20/01/1877 | View match | |
| Pilgrims v Ramblers 03/11/1877 | View match | |
| Ramblers v Pilgrims 09/11/1877 | View match | |
| Royal Engineers v Pilgrims 08/12/1877 | View match | |
| Brentwood Town v Pilgrims 09/11/1878 | View match |