| Walsall FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 20/10/1956 | £35.00 | |
| Brighton & Hove Albion FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 06/04/1957 | £6.99 | |
| Walsall FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 03/03/1958 | £30.00 | |
| Bury FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 08/09/1958 | £15.00 | |
| Southampton FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 29/11/1958 | £9.99 | |
| Brentford FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 27/03/1959 | £12.99 | |
| Liverpool FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 26/09/1959 | £13.99 | |
| Plymouth Argyle FC v Luton Town FC 03/09/1960 | £15.99 | |
| Plymouth Argyle FC v Southport 12/10/1960 | £10.00 | |
| Leyton Orient FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 07/03/1961 | £7.00 | |
| Southampton FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 11/03/1961 | £5.00 | |
| Brighton & Hove Albion FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 31/03/1961 | £5.50 |