| Solihull Moors v Sutton United 08/10/2019 | View match | |
| Sutton United v Ebbsfleet United 26/10/2019 | View match | |
| Sutton United v FC Halifax Town 29/10/2019 | View match | |
| Barrow AFC v Sutton United 02/11/2019 | View match | |
| Torquay United FC v Sutton United 16/11/2019 | View match | |
| Sutton United v Bromley FC 23/11/2019 | View match | |
| Dagenham & Redbridge v Sutton United 26/11/2019 | View match | |
| Sutton United v Harrogate Town 30/11/2019 | View match | |
| Notts County FC v Sutton United 07/12/2019 | View match | |
| AFC Fylde v Sutton United 10/12/2019 | View match | |
| Sutton United v Wrexham FC 21/12/2019 | View match | |
| Woking FC v Sutton United 26/12/2019 | View match |